Report Card Comments: Evidence, Progress, Next Steps
Write specific report card comments from classroom evidence, describe progress fairly, and give families one useful next step.
How to write Ontario learning skills and work habits comments for the fall progress report and the provincial report cards, with the six skills, the E, G, S, N scale and an original comment bank for every skill and level.

Ontario report cards for Grades 1 to 12 rate six learning skills and work habits (Responsibility, Organization, Independent Work, Collaboration, Initiative and Self-Regulation) with four letters: E for Excellent, G for Good, S for Satisfactory and N for Needs Improvement. In Grades 1 to 8, the homeroom teacher usually completes that section and adds a comment on the student’s strengths and next steps for improvement.
This guide explains what the ministry policy says, gives a simple structure for each comment, then offers an original comment bank for every skill and level and a worked example that turns classroom notes into a finished comment.
The policy is Growing Success: Assessment, Evaluation, and Reporting in Ontario Schools (2010). The ministry’s Growing Success page on ontario.ca states that the document still reflects current policy and lists the updates made since 2010, such as reporting language and mathematics as one overall grade in Grades 1 to 8. None of those updates changes the six learning skills or the letter scale. The parent page on student assessment and report cards summarizes the same rules in plain language.
Three points from Growing Success shape every learning skills comment:
Kindergarten reporting follows a separate addendum, so this guide covers Grades 1 to 8.
Growing Success gives sample behaviours for each skill. The ministry says these examples are meant to guide teachers, not to limit them, and that they will look different at different grade levels. The table below paraphrases them so you can see what evidence to collect.
| Skill | What it looks like in class (paraphrased) |
|---|---|
| Responsibility | Meets commitments, hands in work on agreed timelines, manages own behaviour |
| Organization | Makes and follows a plan, sets priorities and manages time, finds and uses information and resources |
| Independent Work | Monitors and adjusts own plans, uses class time well, follows instructions with little supervision |
| Collaboration | Takes on group roles and a fair share of work, respects others’ ideas, builds healthy relationships, helps resolve conflicts, shares resources |
| Initiative | Seeks out new ideas and learning, takes reasonable risks, shows curiosity, approaches new tasks positively, advocates for self and others |
| Self-Regulation | Sets goals and tracks progress, asks for help when needed, reflects on strengths and needs, chooses strategies, perseveres through challenges |
The ontario.ca parent page adds one practical point: if a student consistently misses assignments or hands work in late, this may be reflected in the learning skills section rather than in the subject grade.
The four letter symbols are set by Growing Success:
| Letter | Meaning |
|---|---|
| E | Excellent |
| G | Good |
| S | Satisfactory |
| N | Needs Improvement |
Growing Success does not define each letter with a frequency rule such as “always” or “usually”. Some boards give their staff descriptors, so check your board’s guidance before you settle on wording. Whatever your board uses, base the letter on several observations across the reporting period, not on one bad week or one excellent project.
Elementary schools in Ontario issue three formal reports. Growing Success and the ontario.ca page give the windows; your board sets the exact dates.
| Report | Window | What it reports |
|---|---|---|
| Elementary Progress Report Card | October 20 to November 20 | Learning skills in the fall, plus progress in each subject: Progressing With Difficulty, Progressing Well or Progressing Very Well |
| First provincial report card | January 20 to February 20 | Learning skills, then grades or marks with comments |
| Second provincial report card | End of June | Learning skills, then grades or marks with comments |
Progress report comments matter because the fall report is the first formal message home. Growing Success notes that, on the progress report, you do not need to comment on every subject in the single comment space.
Growing Success asks teachers to write comments that are personalized, clear and precise, in language parents understand, without simply repeating curriculum or achievement chart wording. Comments should name significant strengths, identify next steps and, where possible, help parents see how they can support learning at home. The policy also says boards should not stop teachers from writing personalized comments and that principals are expected to encourage teachers to write their own.
A reliable structure has four moves:
Copyable text
Copy includes the complete text. No signup needed.
Learning skills comment planner
Student: Report: Progress / Report 1 / Report 2
Ratings: R __ O __ IW __ C __ I __ SR __
Strongest skill and evidence (date, task, what you saw):
Skill to grow and evidence:
Next step at school (one action, observable):
Support at home (one small suggestion):
Draft comment (3 to 5 sentences, plain language)
Check: personal? evidence-based? one next step? matches the letters?
For the general method behind evidence, progress and next steps, see our guide to report card comments, which also covers sensitive situations and multilingual learners.
Use this article as context, then create an editable lesson draft to review.
These comments are original examples written for this page. Replace [Name] and adjust the evidence so every comment describes your student, not a generic one. Each line is a starting point, not a finished comment.
If you are drafting for a whole class, the report card comment generator turns short notes for each student into draft comments that you then review and edit, which keeps the personalized writing Growing Success expects.
Here is a fictional Grade 3 student, Amira, in early November.
| Skill | Letter | Evidence from notes |
|---|---|---|
| Responsibility | G | 9 of 10 home reading logs returned; forgot library books twice |
| Organization | S | Needed the planning sheet for the community poster project |
| Independent Work | G | Works steadily during math practice; checks in once per task |
| Collaboration | E | Mediated a disagreement in her science group on October 15 |
| Initiative | E | Brought in a bird nest and led a short class discussion |
| Self-Regulation | S | Becomes frustrated with long writing tasks; asks for help late |
Finished learning skills comment:
Amira is a thoughtful and caring group member. During our science investigation she helped her group settle a disagreement by suggesting they test both ideas. Her curiosity enriches the class, and she led a discussion about a bird nest she brought from home. Amira’s next step is to ask for help earlier when a writing task feels long, using the “first, then” planning card we practise in class. At home, breaking homework into two short parts with a break in between would support this goal.
The comment gives two strengths with evidence, one next step tied to an S, one home suggestion and no curriculum jargon.
Responsibility, Organization, Independent Work, Collaboration, Initiative and Self-Regulation. They appear on the progress report card and the provincial report cards from Grade 1 to Grade 12, as set out in Growing Success.
E means Excellent, G means Good, S means Satisfactory and N means Needs Improvement. Each of the six learning skills receives one of these letters.
Growing Success sets the window between October 20 and November 20. The first provincial report card goes home between January 20 and February 20 and the second near the end of June. Your board sets the exact dates.
To the extent possible, no. Growing Success asks teachers to report learning skills separately from achievement of curriculum expectations. Some expectations, such as the Living Skills in health and physical education, include aspects of these skills and are evaluated as part of the subject.
Yes, as a starting point. Growing Success expects comments to be personalized, and it asks boards not to prevent teachers from writing their own. Use a bank like the one above for structure and vocabulary, then add the evidence that only you have seen.
2 free lessons
The way your tool built the lesson struck me as simple, clear, precise.