Skip to content

DOK Levels: How to Plan a Lesson That Climbs Webb's Depth of Knowledge

The four Webb’s Depth of Knowledge levels explained for lesson planning, with question stems, tasks by level, a copyable template and a Grade 5 science lesson that climbs from DOK 1 to DOK 3.

Wooden risers stepping up across a classroom table, with pond-creature picture cards loose, then sorted into bowls, then arranged in a food web on a paper scroll, and on top a clipboard, a jar of pond water and a magnifying glass.

DOK levels describe how complex the thinking in a task is. Webb’s Depth of Knowledge sorts tasks, standards and test items into four levels: recall, skill or concept, strategic thinking, and extended thinking. Many US districts and state assessment programs use those labels, so teachers are often asked to tag lesson objectives and checks with a DOK level.

This page explains the four levels from the original sources, shows how DOK differs from Bloom’s taxonomy, and gives you question stems, tasks by level, a copyable planning template and a complete Grade 5 science lesson that climbs from DOK 1 to DOK 3.

Where Depth of Knowledge comes from

Norman L. Webb developed Depth of Knowledge as part of his work on alignment: checking whether a test asks for the same kind of thinking as the standards it claims to measure. His 1997 report, Criteria for Alignment of Expectations and Assessments in Mathematics and Science Education (Research Monograph No. 6, ERIC record), was published by the National Institute for Science Education at the University of Wisconsin-Madison with the Council of Chief State School Officers. Later work by Webb set out level definitions for reading, writing, mathematics, science and social studies.

Today WebbAlign, a program of the Wisconsin Center for Education Products and Services, says it works directly with Dr. Webb. Its DOK overview describes DOK as a way to talk about the content complexity of learning expectations, materials and assessment items, and stresses that complexity is not the same as difficulty.

That point matters for planning. The Kansas State Department of Education math DOK page shows it with addition: solving one long addition problem is recall of a known procedure, while using the digits 0 to 9 to build number sentences under constraints asks for more decisions and therefore a higher level. Bigger numbers make a problem harder. They do not make it deeper.

The four DOK levels

The definitions below paraphrase the mathematics DOK descriptions published by the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction, which follow Webb’s wording. Other subjects use the same four names with subject-specific detail.

LevelNameWhat the task demandsTypical evidence
DOK 1RecallRecall a fact, term, definition or simple procedure; apply a formula or a one-step routine.Label, list, define, compute a routine problem.
DOK 2Skill/ConceptSome mental processing beyond a habitual response: students decide how to approach the problem.Classify, compare data, organize and display data, estimate, explain a simple relationship.
DOK 3Strategic ThinkingReasoning, planning and using evidence; explaining thinking; justifying one answer among several.Draw conclusions from observations, build an argument with evidence, solve a non-routine problem.
DOK 4Extended ThinkingComplex reasoning and planning, most likely over an extended period, connecting ideas within or across content areas.Design and run an investigation, synthesize several sources into a new product, critique a design.

Two details from the North Carolina definitions are easy to miss:

  • The verb does not decide the level. “Explain” or “describe” can sit at different levels depending on what students must explain. Explaining a simple relationship can be DOK 2; explaining reasoning from evidence is usually DOK 3.
  • Time alone does not make DOK 4. Recording a river’s temperature every day for a month and graphing it is still DOK 2. A river study that weighs several variables and requires students to choose an approach is DOK 4.

DOK is not Bloom’s taxonomy

Bloom’s taxonomy and DOK answer different questions. In the ISTE and ASCD article What Exactly Is Depth of Knowledge? (Hint: It’s Not a Wheel!), Erik Francis explains that Bloom’s identifies the kind of thinking students do, usually the verb in an objective, while DOK describes the context in which that thinking is shown and how deeply it must be transferred.

In practice:

  • Bloom’s asks: what cognitive process? Remember, understand, apply, analyze, evaluate, create. See our Bloom’s taxonomy lesson plan and the Bloom’s taxonomy verbs list.
  • DOK asks: how complex is what comes after the verb? “Analyze” a two-row table and “analyze” three conflicting data sets share a verb but not a level.

The same article notes that the popular “DOK wheel”, which arranges verbs in rings by level, was not designed by Webb. Use verb lists to write clear objectives, then judge the DOK level from the whole task. Karin Hess and colleagues combined the two frameworks in the Cognitive Rigor Matrix, which the Kansas page links, if your district wants both labels on one grid.

DOK question stems you can use

These stems are starting points. Check the level against the full task, not the stem alone.

DOK 1: Recall

  • What is the definition of ...?
  • Label the parts of ...
  • Which of these is an example of ...?
  • Calculate ... using the formula we learned.

DOK 2: Skill/Concept

  • How are ... and ... alike and different?
  • Sort these ... into groups and name your rule.
  • What pattern do you see in this table?
  • Estimate ... and explain how you got your estimate.

DOK 3: Strategic Thinking

  • What evidence from the data supports your claim?
  • Which solution is better, and why? Use two reasons.
  • What would happen if ... changed? Justify your prediction.
  • Explain why this strategy works for this problem but not that one.

DOK 4: Extended Thinking

  • Design an investigation to test ... and report what you find.
  • Compare the arguments in three sources and propose your own position.
  • Apply what you learned in this unit to a problem in our community.

Tasks by DOK level and subject

SubjectDOK 1DOK 2DOK 3DOK 4
MathSolve 4 routine two-digit multiplications.Choose and draw a model that shows 3 x 14.Decide which of two pricing plans is cheaper for different months and justify the break-even point.Plan a class fundraiser budget using real prices collected over two weeks.
ELAIdentify the narrator of a story.Compare two characters’ motives using a T-chart.Write a claim about the theme and support it with three quotations.Research an author across several texts and write an analytical essay.
ScienceName the parts of a plant.Classify organisms as producers, consumers or decomposers.Use pond data to argue what happens if one species disappears.Monitor a local habitat over weeks and propose an evidence-based change.
Social studiesList the three branches of government.Explain how a bill becomes law with a flow chart.Evaluate which source gives the more reliable account of an event.Investigate a local issue and present a proposal to a real audience.

Notice that DOK 4 tasks span days or weeks. A single 45-minute period can reach DOK 3, and a unit can include a DOK 4 project.

Copyable DOK lesson planning template

Copyable text

Copy includes the complete text. No signup needed.

Lesson title:

Grade and subject:

Standard (state code and wording):

DOK level of the standard (as your state or district rates it):

Objective(s):

- Objective 1 (DOK __):

- Objective 2 (DOK __):

Show full text

Lesson sequence (climb, do not jump)

1. Opener, DOK 1: recall needed facts or vocabulary.

Task:

Check:

2. Build, DOK 2: apply, classify, compare or organize.

Task:

Check:

3. Stretch, DOK 3: reason with evidence, justify, solve a non-routine problem.

Task:

Check:

4. Unit link, DOK 4 (only if the unit includes an extended task):

Next step in the project:

Questions to ask at each level:

- DOK 1:

- DOK 2:

- DOK 3:

Exit ticket (match the highest DOK level of the objective):

Support for students who need it (keep the same DOK level):

Extension (go deeper, not just longer):

The two rules built into the template are the ones that matter: each check matches the level of its task, and support changes the scaffolding, not the level of thinking expected.

Worked example: Grade 5 science, food webs in a pond

Context: Grade 5, 24 students, 50-minute period. Students know the words producer and consumer from Grade 4.

Standard: your state’s Grade 5 life science standard on how matter and energy move among plants, animals, decomposers and the environment. Write the exact code and wording from your state document.

Objectives:

  • Students will classify pond organisms as producers, consumers or decomposers and draw a food web with at least eight correct arrows (DOK 2).
  • Students will predict how removing one organism changes the food web and justify the prediction with two pieces of evidence from the web (DOK 3).

Materials: organism cards with pictures and diet notes, chart paper, markers, a short data table showing pond populations over three seasons, exit ticket slips.

TimePhase and DOKWhat happensCheck
0 to 7 minOpener, DOK 1Quick quiz on whiteboards: define producer, consumer, decomposer; label the direction an arrow points in a food chain.All boards up; reteach arrow direction if more than four students reverse it.
7 to 20 minBuild, DOK 2In groups of four, students sort 12 organism cards into three groups, then build a food web on chart paper from the diet notes.Each group explains one sorting decision to the teacher.
20 to 25 minGallery checkGroups compare webs and fix arrows that disagree with the diet notes.Teacher marks webs with fewer than eight correct arrows for a quick conference.
25 to 42 minStretch, DOK 3Each group receives a scenario: the frogs disappear from the pond. Students use their web and the population table to predict two effects and justify them in a claim, evidence and reasoning paragraph.Teacher listens for “because” statements tied to specific arrows or numbers.
42 to 50 minExit ticket, DOK 3Individual task: “If the algae died off, which organism would be affected last? Explain using the web.”Sort tickets into: correct with reasoning, correct without reasoning, incorrect.

Support at the same level: a sentence frame for the DOK 3 paragraph (“If ... disappeared, then ... would ... because the web shows ...”), and organism cards with diet arrows already started for two students who need it. The thinking demand stays at DOK 3.

Unit link to DOK 4: over the next two weeks, the class monitors a schoolyard habitat or aquarium, records observations, and proposes one change that would support more organisms. That extended task is where DOK 4 belongs.

For more ways to turn the exit ticket into next-day groups, see our exit ticket templates and examples.

Common mistakes when planning with DOK

  1. Tagging by verb. “Explain” does not guarantee DOK 3. Read the whole task and ask how many decisions students make.
  2. Making it harder instead of deeper. Larger numbers, longer texts or more problems raise difficulty, not DOK.
  3. Jumping straight to DOK 3. Students need the DOK 1 vocabulary and DOK 2 organization first, or the DOK 3 task turns into guessing.
  4. Calling a long project DOK 4 automatically. Extended time counts only when the work requires sustained reasoning and choices, not repetition.
  5. Lowering the level as support. Scaffold with frames, models and grouping, but keep the expected thinking at the planned level.
  6. Mismatched checks. A DOK 3 objective needs a DOK 3 check; a multiple-choice recall item cannot show it. Our guide to lesson plan objectives shows how to write objectives that point to a matching check.

Frequently asked questions

What are the 4 DOK levels?

Webb’s four Depth of Knowledge levels are DOK 1 Recall, DOK 2 Skill/Concept, DOK 3 Strategic Thinking and DOK 4 Extended Thinking. They describe the complexity of the thinking a task requires, from recalling a fact to complex reasoning carried out over an extended period.

Is DOK the same as Bloom’s taxonomy?

No. Bloom’s names the type of cognitive process, usually the verb in an objective. DOK rates how complex the task around that verb is. The same verb can appear at several DOK levels, which is why verb wheels are not a reliable way to assign a level.

What is an example of a DOK 3 question?

“Which of these two plans is cheaper over a year, and what evidence supports your answer?” Students must reason, choose a method and justify the result with evidence, which matches the DOK 3 description.

Can a single lesson reach DOK 4?

Rarely. DOK 4 describes complex work that most likely takes an extended period. Plan lessons that climb to DOK 3 and place DOK 4 in a multi-day project or unit task.

Where can I find official DOK definitions for my subject?

Start with WebbAlign’s DOK definitions page, which lists documents for math, reading, science and social studies, then check your state department of education, since many states publish their own DOK guidance for state assessments.

Keep planning